Skip to Content

Neighbors Bank Reviews

Unedited reviews from borrowers nationwide

6,483

Total Customer Reviews

96%

Would recommend Neighbors Bank

4.7 out of 5

Average Satisfaction Rating

    Showing all 6,483 unfiltered reviews

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Tennessee Would Recommend

    Feb 11, 2026

    Kevin Osterhaus, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Kevin Osterhaus

    NMLS#1960695

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    My husband and I are first time homebuyers. We were nervous about the process, especially having our hands full with a one year old and another on the way. Our loan team was AMAZING! Jessica Jamison and Kara Muenks made the process not only easy, but helped give us confidence the whole way through to owning our beautiful home. They were fast to answer questions and never made us feel like an inconvenience. We can't say enough incredible things about our experience and are truly grateful to Neighbors Bank for taking a major life milestone and turning it into a lifelong, wonderful memory for us and our family!

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in West Virginia Would Recommend

    I have several obstacles that came about and they were fantastic to work with me during those times

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Feb 10, 2026

    Nathan Groves, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Nathan Groves

    NMLS#1096165

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Florida Would Recommend

    Neighbors Bank has very friendly staff and confidently guided us in the process of the home loan and what is to be expected. Tasha, Tyler and Chad were the best in making the process run smoothly. Thank you Neighbors Bank!

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Feb 9, 2026

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: No cash-out refinance

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Pennsylvania Would Recommend

    I had a great experience with Neighbors bank throughout my home loan process. From pre-approval through clear-to-close, their team was organized, transparent, and very responsive whenever I had questions or needed clarification on documents or numbers.The closing process was handled efficiently, and I always felt like my file was being actively managed rather than sitting in a queue. They were also very clear about requirements and timelines, which helped me prepare and avoid last-minute surprises.Overall, the process was smooth, professional, and much less stressful than I expected. I would definitely consider working with them again and recommend them to others purchasing a home.

    Derek Wilson, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Derek Wilson

    NMLS#2653342

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Florida Would Recommend

    Every step of the way my loan team was receptive to all my questions and communication to me was swift and pleasant. Even my title person commented more than once how awesome my loan team was.

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Illinois Would Recommend

    Shannon and Kathleen were great! Both were quick to respond with any questions we had as well as very informative throughout the entire process.

    Shannon Matlack, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Shannon Matlack

    NMLS#982020

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Michigan Would Recommend

    I had a crazy dream and timeline that Max H. & Derek W. made it happen! After some long work nights as well as millions of docusigns I was very grateful for the lending team I was giving purchasing my first home! Thanks Neighbors Bank!

    Derek Wilson, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Derek Wilson

    NMLS#2653342

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Indiana Would Recommend

    My team is great! I was family not just a name. Knowledgeable friendly helpful all the best qualities Julia, Kellie and Cooper are awesome They were my support during the good and the bad Mostly all Good. Five GOLD Stars to all of them! Keep up the GOOD Work. Best of Luck to all.

    Cooper Allen, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Cooper Allen

    NMLS#170363

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Mississippi Would Recommend

    I recently worked with Neighbors Bank for my home purchase and I could not be happier with my experience. From start to finish, the team was wonderful—attentive to my needs and always available to answer my questions. They made what could have been a stressful process feel incredibly easy and straightforward. I was genuinely impressed by their professionalism and the care they showed throughout every step. Neighbors Bank went above and beyond to ensure that everything was handled smoothly, and I truly appreciated their dedication. Thanks to their support, I was able to purchase my home with confidence and peace of mind. I highly recommend Neighbors Bank to anyone looking for a lender who values customer service and makes the home buying process stress-free.

    Rob Parham, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Rob Parham

    NMLS#1524830

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. The Neighbors Bank portal is very user friendly which makes it much easier and faster for uploading documents, reviewing documents and communicating with the Loan Officer.

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: No cash-out refinance

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Louisiana Would Recommend

    Joey and Alyssa were the best people for the job. Always available and quick to find answers to our questions. This was the first mortgage we have ever gotten and we were very happy with the team we got.

    Joey Mirth, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Joey Mirth

    NMLS#1965551

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Indiana Would Recommend

    Feb 6, 2026

    Bentley Stilwell, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Bentley Stilwell

    NMLS#2355453

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Kansas Would Recommend

    Everyone was Quick, straightforward, and helpful at every step especially since we were first-time buyers!

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Florida Would Recommend

    Feb 6, 2026

    Marissa Nichols, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Marissa Nichols

    NMLS#902827

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Mississippi Would Recommend

    Our had an awesome team working with me throughout the lender process. Everyone was very kind and super helpful. Big shout out to Carina G., Tyler G., and Chad W. I can’t wait to recommend you all to friends and family that are interested in mortgage loans

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Alabama Would Recommend

    Feb 5, 2026

    Jordan Legg, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jordan Legg

    NMLS#2708514

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Everyone I worked with at Neighbors were great. They did a good job of communicating all steps of our loan and answering any questions which helped us start and close the loan quickly with no issues.

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: Refinance

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Alabama Would Recommend

    Feb 5, 2026

    Easy to work with and understanding and patient. Smooth process overall.

    Rob Parham, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Rob Parham

    NMLS#1524830

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Virginia Would Recommend

    Bentley Stilwell was absolutely outstanding during this tedious process! She made things easy, and communicated well throughout the whole process! Professional while still personable. Thank you Neighbors Bank for helping us with our first home purchase! 🏡

    Bentley Stilwell, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Bentley Stilwell

    NMLS#2355453

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in South Carolina Would Recommend

    Feb 4, 2026

    Kerry Alexander was very helpful and informative and the other Neighbors associates we worked with were helpful and informative.

    Kerry Alexander, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Kerry Alexander

    NMLS#2653612

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Louisiana Would Recommend

    Feb 4, 2026

    Chris Yackley, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chris Yackley

    NMLS#2110129

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Tennessee Would Recommend

    Feb 3, 2026

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Iowa Would Recommend

    Everyone who helped us over the last 2 months was extreamly helpful. They stayed on top of everything so we could close on time and helped to get things at a price we could afford. They kept us up to date on the process as well and helped work with our realtor to get things done.

    Lee Franklin, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Lee Franklin

    NMLS#1990666

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Minnesota Would Recommend

    Feb 3, 2026

    Paden Klein, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Paden Klein

    NMLS#2589666

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Alyssa was extremely helpful. Her communication between me, my loan officer Steve and the underwriting team was the absolute best. I had a great experience for buying my very first home.

    Steve Taurman, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Steve Taurman

    NMLS#1130035

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Rachel, Jessica, and Derek were amazing! As first-time home buyers, we were nervous and unsure of how the process would work, but the team at Neighbors Bank were always on the ready to answer our questions and made the whole process far more comfortable than we could have ever imagined. I am deeply appreciative of all that they have done for us, and I HIGHLY recommend Neighbors Bank! 15 out of 10!!

    Jessica Seek, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Seek

    NMLS#2110132

    Loan type: Purchase

Send Your Feedback

We want to hear about your experience with Neighbors Bank!

Send your feedback »

Find the Right Mortgage for You
1,881 families started their quote today.